Public Education: What The Opposition Refuses to See

By Karen Vieth

I have been in touch with many Wisconsin families this past year to discuss the political climate, particularly its effects on education. This outreach has been extremely beneficial to me and to those on the other side of the door or at the other end of the phone line. In general, when I contact someone who clearly “stands with” Governor Walker, I politely end the conversation and move on to the next door or phone call. Dealings within my own family taught me long ago that when individuals set in their ways are confronted, they oftentimes dig in their heels even deeper. However, a few nights ago I was feeling particularly feisty, and so I decided to engage the Walker fanatics on the phones. Doing so did not improve my disposition or raise my spirits, but it did give me a clear vision of what we are up against. We are fighting against ignorance, hatred, apathy, and people who refuse see the truth about teachers and public education.

With a Walker supporter on the line, my first question was, “What about the $1.6 billion dollars cut from education? Does that worry you at all?” The response I received from each Walker follower was, “No, not at all.” And when I asked about class size, an even bigger alarm bell rang. One person I talked to thought that 50 – 60 would be a fine class size. She also thought the budget cuts were okay, because we have “too much” technology in the schools. In her mind, this is why some of our kids aren’t able to read; nobody is teaching them. Teachers and students are too busy “messing with computers.” But the biggest shock came when discussing educational assistants and paraprofessionals. The response was, “We wouldn’t need those aides if teachers would just do their jobs. Those positions should be cut.” When I started to list some programming that has been cut under Walker’s administration, the rebuttal was an accusation, “The only reason you teachers are involved is because you don’t want to pay your pension and health care.” While these types of phone calls were in the minority that night, they made an impact. The calls left me trembling and afraid for our future. This led to days of me walking the halls of my school, purposefully seeing even more vividly what they do not. Here is some of what I see.

In the morning, kids gather in the building, many of them getting their breakfast at school so that they will be focused on learning rather than their hunger. Walking down the hall to my classroom, I notice a special education assistant pushing a child in a wheelchair while sharing a joke. There are goofy expressions on each of their faces.

In the afternoon, I see kids in classes learning and teachers kneeling beside them offering guidance. Special education assistants are in the rooms dealing with some of our neediest populations, sometimes taking a kick or getting scratched without complaint. Professionals with Master’s degrees are bathrooming or feeding special education students, because there is a need. Later in the day, the whole school gathers for our “Fun Run.” They are gearing up for a real life lesson on human health and awareness. Staff run alongside students, encouraging them and providing support. After the run, the school population takes the bleachers, applauding the succeses of this tightly knit community.

After school, the building is still alive with activity. Many students stay after school to get homework help. This one on one attention is something the students cherish; you can see the eagerness in their eyes and the smiles on their faces when they receive positive reinforcement. After hours, devoted teachers stay late, sometimes well past dinner time. It isn’t something they do for the money; clearly there is no overtime pay. They make these efforts for their students; it is the reason that they are in this profession.

I see a lot of greatness within the walls of my school, but lately I am also tuned in to the sadness. The post Act 10 world is already bleak. Staff morale is at an all-time low. Current legislation and rulings, such as the new definition of base wage, are reason to worry. While the Madison teachers are protected by a contract for one more year, friends in neighboring districts tell us tales of their life with “teacher handbooks” rather than contracts. Stories of longer school days without compensation or positions lost without just cause reach our ears. We are already having to say goodbye to some of our friends who have been laid off. We wonder what else is to come. The uncertainty hangs heavy on everyone’s minds while we continue to do what is best for our students.

Many of us find it harder and harder to do our jobs. Over half of my students live in poverty. Shopping for school supplies and stocking my cabinets for the students has always been a part of my job. When a student can’t come up with the funding for a field trip, I have never had a problem chipping in a few extra dollars. This year, I struggle. Due to the recent cuts in my pay, I don’t always have that extra dollar to help out. I live in a single income household. I’m still paying back that Master’s degree that is no longer included as part of my base pay. Money that used to flow from my paycheck into my classroom is not there. It is a horrible feeling. Because of cuts to programs and services, my students’ families hurt more and more under Walker’s rule. At the same time, I find myself able to help them less and less.

As Election Day looms nearer, I get more and more anxious about the years to come. Changes in staffing have made my job more difficult every year. Next year will be the most challenging to date. Budget cuts made now result in a direct change in programming, services, and student to teacher ratios. Those left in the schools have to figure out a way to take on additional responsibilities with dwindling resources.

Thinking back to those calls, I wonder how some of our public has gotten so out of touch. Quality, public education is the keystone to a successful democracy. Educated citizens are able to lift up our community and make it greater than before. Mohatma Gandhi said, “A nation’s greatness is measured by how it treats its weakest members.” He saw what some of those stricken with greed in our society cannot: we are all in this together. There is no greatness that excludes and puts down populations in need. One of the reasons our public education is so important is that it is one of the only systems in our society that welcomes everyone through its doors. When people let loose hatred on these institutions and our government withdraws its funding, we all suffer.

I plan on taking this battle to the polls. There is no time to sit idly by or to let my pessimism and fear prevent me from action. I will continue to knock on the doors of my neighbors and to speak a truth that some may not be ready to hear. The future of public education, my students, and our society depends on it. If we all speak some truth on June 5th, those who are choosing not to truly see us will get their wake up call.

6 thoughts on “Public Education: What The Opposition Refuses to See

  1. Colin,
    I wonder how long your clubs and honors classes can stay intact when the second round of budget cut hits. Just something to think about.
    As a teacher, I want what is best for my students. Being an honor student and leader you must surely understand the concept of a common good. How we treat those that can help themselves the least is how societies are judged. It’s really very simple to understand, defunding schools defunds our children. I am sorry that teachers have left young high and dry on occasion. Perhaps your energies might be better placed taking up the matter with those teachers to help solve the problem for others.
    In any event you should avoid sounding like the child you are instead of the leader you hope to be.

    • My name is Corin, with an R, thank you kindly. For you to call me a child merely for being as frustrated with the current political climate as the next person is unnecessarily patronizing. Do not assume that age is all that it takes to have prescience with these matters.

      The simple truth is that cuts need to be made to balance our state’s budget. You can argue until the cows come home about what area you feel is more appropriate to take these budget cuts than education, but consider that your personal involvement in the education system may be introducing a bias to your perception. Another clear fact is that under Governor Doyle, countless excess dollars were sent to education and little improvement was seen other than new, flashy facilities for some schools. Money doesn’t educate children, good teaching does. If you care about the students as much as you claim to, then you will continue to serve them to the best of your ability in spite of cuts.

      Reform is also required at the district level. Funds provided from the state governmentand from local property tax dollars need to be allocated more judiciously. Perhaps some staff members will have to be laid off, and while this is unfortunate, these are the economic times we face. As for honors classes and clubs, where there is a will there is a way. When my high school planned to cut our AP Statistics course because enrollment was too low to justify funding it, our teacher chose to gather the necessary funds to purchase all the Statistics course books and calculators himself and as such convinced the schoil to continue to offer the course. Here is an example of an excellent teacher. Rather than spending time complaining about the cuts that are necessary for the reality of our state’s budget, he found a solution.

      Returning to my focus from my previous post, I still maintain that teachers are out of line when they protest to contributing more towards the cost of their benefits. Employees in the private sector have footed these costs for years. It is not unreasonable to expect the same of public employees for the sake of continued greater good for the students.

      While I’m sure you won’t be swayed by any of my words because you seem to be under the impression that I am a “child” who is screaming out of ignorance, rather than an adult presenting frustrations that he finds (as many others are doing also), I hope that at the very least you recognize the bias that may be skewing your vision of this issue. Imagine yourself in the shoes of a person employed outside of the public sector. Think for just a moment about whether your feelings would be the same coming from a different perspective.

  2. Oh I’m sorry, you have to pay for your benefits now? How dreadful. Oh I’m sorry, you now don’t make drastically more than my father who works at a private university, and is far more qualified than you with a PhD he earned in 8 years flat? How dreadful. You talk about greed. Why don’t you mention your greed. Teachers in public education always have their hands out for more, and apparently because one teacher stays late all teachers deserve greater compensation? I can’t count how many times, as a student taking 8 honors classes and holding leadership positions in 5 clubs, I arranged in advance after school times to meet with teachers that they did not show up to. Before you complain about the “greed” of others, why don’t you analyze your own greed? Exactly how is it greedy for private sector employees to expect you to pay equally towards the cost of your health benefits? Do you see us getting a check in the mail when you get paid less? NO. We just pay a minimal amount less into our property taxes to feed YOUR greedy hands like we have for ALL THESE YEARS. Before you call others ignorant for not giving you everything you want, analyze OUR side too thank you very much.

    • Corin:
      I don’t understand how you decided that teachers are greedy. Did you mean greedy in the sense of wall street financiers that make many millions of dollars a year? Did you mean greedy in the sense of CEOs getting hundreds of millions of dollars when they leave their company because of their company’s low performance? If you meant that kind of greed, then I think you have teachers confused with the 1%. That’s a disjoint set Corin.

      Or were you referring to the greed of some taxpayers that want great school systems but are unwilling to pay for them? Or taxpayers that want the kids in their community to grow up to have better jobs and better lives than their parents, but are unwilling to pay for that?

      Greed is defined by Wikipedia as, “the inordinate desire to possess wealth, goods, or objects of abstract value with the intention to keep it for one’s self, far beyond the dictates of basic survival and comfort.” Do you know teachers that are wealthy? Do you know teachers that drive high-priced cars (that they paid for out of their own salary)? Yes, I have a 1996 Land Rover Discovery, that I paid for when I was a software engineer making a very good salary. Now, as a math and computer science public school teacher, I can’t afford a rusty used $1000 pickup. Goods? Nope, we can’t afford to buy any high-priced goods on my salary.

      Why is it greedy to expect the people that pay my salary (taxpayers) to also help pay for my retirement? Would you expect all teachers to live on the streets when they retire? Or would you want them to continue to help your community’s economy when they retire?

      How are you contributing to your local community Corin? How are you helping the kids in your community to better themselves? It sounds to me like the author goes above and beyond her duty as a teacher. How much better would your community be if all members of it did that?

      Jack S.
      Proud to be a public school teacher

    • What an unfairly vitriolic response to a crie de coeur that most of us in the third world would be able to identify with. The response itself speaks volumes about the validity of Karen’s blog, and is the reason for America’s slide into third world sloveliness. Shame on you, Corin, whoever you are.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s